Exclusive-Mexico’s CFE ordered to pay Canada firm $85 million in arbitration case

Published: Oct 3, 2022, 23:51 GMT+00:00

By Dave Graham and Stefanie Eschenbacher

The logo of Mexico's state-run electric utility known as the CFE, is pictured at its building office in Monterrey

By Dave Graham and Stefanie Eschenbacher

MEXICO CITY (Reuters) – Mexican state power utility Comision Federal de Electricidad (CFE) last year lost an international arbitration case to Canadian firm ATCO Ltd , and had to pay redress of about $85 million, according to three people familiar with the matter.

Though the case relates to a pipeline contracted by the previous Mexican government, it offers an indication of the sort of dispute compensation the current administration could have to pay over its contentious moves to tighten state control of the energy market.

The London Court of International Arbitration made the award on the Ramal Tula pipeline to ATCO in October 2021, the sources said. Once legal fees and interest were added, the sum came to around $100 million, which CFE paid ATCO in December, they added.

ATCO could not comment because its contractual dealings with CFE are confidential, a spokesperson said, adding the Canadian firm remained committed to pursuing efficient, lower-emission energy solutions in Mexico. The court declined to comment and CFE did not reply to requests for comment.

ATCO pursued arbitration because after President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador took power in 2018, CFE canceled a contract the last administration agreed with the Canadian firm to build a natural gas pipeline near the central city of Tula on the grounds that the work was incomplete, the sources said.

ATCO had already built most of the 17 kilometer (11 mile) pipeline due to supply a power station. But the firm said it could not finish the final stretch due to resistance by local communities, and therefore invoked force majeure.

The Canadian company argued Mexico had not done enough to enable the pipeline’s completion, and the court agreed, the sources said. Mexico had initially estimated the project was worth $66 million when it was awarded in 2014.

Lopez Obrador has overhauled legislation to bolster the position of CFE and state oil company Petroleos Mexicanos (Pemex) at the expense of independent operators, arguing that past governments skewed the market in favor of private capital.

Still, in July, the U.S. Trade Representative requested dispute settlement talks with Mexico over billions of dollars in energy investments, arguing Lopez Obrador’s policies violated the United States-Mexico-Canada (USMCA) trade agreement.

Canada quickly joined the U.S. complaint, which officials are working to resolve.

CFE said in its 2021 annual report it was facing 21 cases of international arbitration, and had significantly raised its reserves for litigation and lawsuits.

There have, however, been signs that Mexico is finding ways to get past some disputes.

In August, Canadian firm TC Energy said it had sealed a deal with CFE to build a $4.5 billion pipeline in southeast Mexico.

In the announcement, TC Energy said the two sides had agreed to “mutually terminate” international arbitration relating to other pipelines the Canadian firm was building in Mexico.

(Reporting by Dave Graham and Stefanie Eschenbacher; Additional reporting by Nia Williams in Calgary; Editing by Josie Kao)

About the Author


Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the world’s largest international multimedia news provider reaching more than one billion people every day. Reuters provides trusted business, financial, national, and international news to professionals via Thomson Reuters desktops, the world's media organizations, and directly to consumers at and via Reuters TV. Learn more about Thomson Reuters products:

Did you find this article useful?