Francis Menassa, JAR Capital: You Can’t Always Get What You Want

It has been interesting to see equity markets rallying this year into increasing expectations for a Fed rate cut. The backdrop has been one of decelerating earnings growth from US corporates, with a fracturing international trade environment leading to some softening in the economic sentiment indicators.
FX Empire Editorial Board

The factors pointing towards more accommodative monetary policy from the Fed this year. The domestic economy seems to have remained relatively robust, however, with strong consumer spending growth and a fifty-year low in the unemployment rate.

It is these competing economic forces that have been confounding policymakers, eventually leading to the July cut in rates. Judging by recent historical standards, that should drive US equities higher for a while longer, but with markets up over 20% already year to date, and brushing up against all-time highs, how much more should we expect?

Low unemployment rates and inflation

If softer growth expectations are allowing for easier monetary policy, should that really be super bullish for US stocks? With interest rates close to zero can we really expect fixed income investments to diversify away equity risk when the equity bull market comes to an end? These are the issues that investors should be tackling now, considering a rebalance of their portfolios while equity markets are in good shape.

Figure 1 – 50-year low unemployment rate driving up wage growth

Starting with the economic fundamentals, this cycle so far has been marked out by low-interest rates and a supposed breakdown in the Phillips Curve (Figure 2). That is the relationship between unemployment and inflation. The idea being that lower levels of unemployment tighten the labor market which adds to rising wage pressure which in turn pushes up price inflation.

Figure 2 – Phillips curve sleeping?

So far this cycle, we have seen the unemployment rate fall to historic lows, pushing up wage growth (although by less than we would normally expect, Figure 2) but having no effect on inflation. In fact, one of the factors concerning US policymakers has been the fall in core PCE inflation (the Feds preferred measure) at a time when it really should be rising.

That reaction function of policymakers is instructive. It suggests that they are more concerned about the risks for deflation (falling prices) than about inflation running hot above their target. That could be because the normal Fed rate-cutting cycle would usually mean interest rates falling by 5% or so in order to stabilize growth or to push the economy out of recession and back into growth.

This time around there is just half that degree of firepower available to the Fed assuming that interest rates will not fall below zero. Therefore, policymakers are prepared to be proactive and to provide insurance against the possibility of a broad economic slowdown.

Is it the last rate cut?

That to us suggests that it is more likely than not that this cut in rates will be the last for a while, and that the Fed may even be prepared to let the economy run hot for a while in order to shore up the growth situation before adjusting policy again. That would be our central case but let us consider a couple of scenarios around that.

First, the Fed could be successful in reigniting an acceleration in economic growth which would almost certainly drive up bond yields from here. Given the revealed preference of policymakers for insuring growth, that could mean inflation running around 1% above target next year and a significant steepening of the yield curve.

On the other side of the coin, if the growth fundamentals have already deteriorated to the point where policymakers are unable to reignite growth, then the possibility of recession will likely take bond yields below zero, but probably not by much.

In our bullish scenario, where growth reaccelerates, bond yields are likely to rise, making them unattractive to investors today. In our bearish scenario, bond yields are unlikely to fall by enough in order to offer the kind of diversification benefits that balanced multi-asset investors have come to expect. For investors to protect their wealth within a multi-asset context therefore, they will need to look elsewhere in order to diversify away from equity risk. One obvious alternative is the now deep and liquid market for derivatives.

Instead of buying bonds for diversification, investors could buy put options on the equity market, maybe cheaper out of the money contracts which would rally significantly should equity market volatility pick up. The VIX is now towards the lows for the year making this a good opportunity to put in place that kind of portfolio protection, but this approach comes with a cost With bond yields looking so unattractive in either of our scenarios, however, it may be that investors really should consider the prospect of lower portfolio returns or accept a higher level of risk. Either way, investors should make an active choice, and now it seems the time to do it. You can’t always get what you want!

Don't miss a thing!

Discover what's moving the markets. Sign up for a daily update delivered to your inbox

Latest Articles

See All

Expand Your Knowledge

See All
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS
The content provided on the website includes general news and publications, our personal analysis and opinions, and contents provided by third parties, which are intended for educational and research purposes only. It does not constitute, and should not be read as, any recommendation or advice to take any action whatsoever, including to make any investment or buy any product. When making any financial decision, you should perform your own due diligence checks, apply your own discretion and consult your competent advisors. The content of the website is not personally directed to you, and we does not take into account your financial situation or needs.The information contained in this website is not necessarily provided in real-time nor is it necessarily accurate. Prices provided herein may be provided by market makers and not by exchanges.Any trading or other financial decision you make shall be at your full responsibility, and you must not rely on any information provided through the website. FX Empire does not provide any warranty regarding any of the information contained in the website, and shall bear no responsibility for any trading losses you might incur as a result of using any information contained in the website.The website may include advertisements and other promotional contents, and FX Empire may receive compensation from third parties in connection with the content. FX Empire does not endorse any third party or recommends using any third party's services, and does not assume responsibility for your use of any such third party's website or services.FX Empire and its employees, officers, subsidiaries and associates, are not liable nor shall they be held liable for any loss or damage resulting from your use of the website or reliance on the information provided on this website.
RISK DISCLAIMER
This website includes information about cryptocurrencies, contracts for difference (CFDs) and other financial instruments, and about brokers, exchanges and other entities trading in such instruments. Both cryptocurrencies and CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money. You should carefully consider whether you understand how these instruments work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.FX Empire encourages you to perform your own research before making any investment decision, and to avoid investing in any financial instrument which you do not fully understand how it works and what are the risks involved.
FOLLOW US